Episode 170 · Season 7 · ·

The Community Commitment

Carolyn Manning, Chief Marketing Officer at Sage, on why community is a commitment rather than a channel, and why brand is the soil that demand generation harvests.

Carolyn Manning, Chief Marketing Officer, Sage. In conversation with John Horsley.

Read the interview
Share
Carolyn Manning, Chief Marketing Officer at Sage
Carolyn Manning, Sage

The Community Commitment

0:0039:00

From practicing law to 11 years scaling Lululemon, then into technology, healthcare and now caregiving, Carolyn Manning has built a career on community. In this episode she argues that community is a commitment, not a channel, and that brand is the soil demand generation harvests.

Manning put herself through law school and was practicing law when she took a part-time job at Lululemon, which had just opened its first Washington DC store. She started as an educator, the company's word for its sales staff, fell in love with the community side of the business, and stayed for 11 years as the US estate grew from five stores to 250 and the brand went global. She then made the move from physical product to technology at Meetup, a community organising platform, before entering US healthcare at Galileo, applying a direct-to-consumer mindset to a traditionally opaque space. She is now Chief Marketing Officer at Sage, which builds hardware and software, including AI fall detection, for senior living communities and skilled nursing facilities, where the caregivers are the users.

In this conversation with host John Horsley, Manning argues that community is a commitment and not a channel, defined by a simple test: would the people still show up if you never sold them anything? She frames the brand versus demand debate as a false choice, with demand generation as harvesting and community as the thing that keeps the soil arable. She warns that most buyers are not in market at any moment, that AI has made content cheap so the advantage now lies in proprietary data, point of view, relationships and taste, and that automating junior roles today leaves organisations with no bench tomorrow. The job of the chief marketing officer, she says, is moving from owning the message to owning trust.

Community is a thread through your career. What is your philosophy on it?

“I think about whether or not the community would still show up if we never sold them anything.”

I think about community as a commitment and less as a channel. The test is whether the community would still show up if we never sold them anything. The Lululemon ethos was to give without expecting anything in return. If people only show up because they get something, it is transactional, and if they would not show up unless we sold to them, then it is an audience, not a community. That matters most when things unravel, which they do as a brand scales: you lose visibility into factories and quality, you make a public relations misstep, and you need a community that holds you up.

How do you think about brand versus demand?

“The demand generation is harvesting, and, and if you're only harvesting and you, like, you kind of eventually run out of good soil”

I think it is a false choice. Demand generation is harvesting, and if you only harvest you eventually run out of good soil. When short-term pressure hits you have to protect the brand investment and make it accountable by tying it to things you can see. Community is the thing that keeps the soil arable so you retain the ability to harvest at all.

How is AI changing what marketing should value?

“What's left is what really can't be generated, so it's proprietary data, it feels like it's a real point of view, um, and relationships and taste”

When everyone can generate content, content stops being the advantage, which is roughly where we have been for at least five years. What is left is what cannot be generated: proprietary data, a real point of view, relationships and taste. That feels like a pivot back to where a CMO was 15 or 20 years ago, and now that AI is here we get to double down on the things that are uniquely human.

From Business of Marketing

Put yourself forward or recommend a guest for us to consider.

Request an interview →

Are companies automating junior roles too quickly?

“If folks aren't being developed from a career perspective internally, then we don't have that bench, and I think it puts the organization at a real disadvantage”

We are all rushing in, making team structural decisions not supported by enough data. Succession planning gets tricky when you are not hiring people into ground-floor roles where they learn how to become a VP of growth or a CMO, because then there is no bench. We can all spot slop right away and we need a human perspective on it, often from junior people. Teams scale up and down, and when roles move you need people you can ask to pick things up. If folks are not developed internally, you have no bench, and it puts the organisation at a real disadvantage.

How do you see the CMO role changing?

“This function moves from k- kind of owning the messaging to really owning trust”

It is going to be collaborative, and we are all in for a shakeup over the next five to 10 years. The function moves from owning the message to really owning trust. It will be less about production and more about judgment and taste, and closer to product and data, because the customer experience really is the marketing. Right now I am accountable for both revenue and reputation, and I think that continues.

Never miss an episode. Follow Business of Marketing.

Read the full transcript

Lightly edited for readability

Speaker 1: Welcome to the Business of Marketing. My name's John Horsley, I'm the host of the show today. Um, I'm absolutely delighted to be joined by Carolyn Manning, who is Chief Marketing Officer at Sage. Welcome to the show.

Speaker 2: Thanks, John. I'm really happy to be here.

Speaker 1: Um, yeah, absolutely delighted, um, for you to join me today. Just as a starter for 10 or an introduction for our listeners-

Speaker 2: Sure

Speaker 1: ... what was it in the first place that, uh, caught your attention and drew you into the world of marketing? I know in the past that your early career you were a, a, a lawyer, you were an attorney.

Speaker 2: Yeah.

Speaker 1: So what was it? What was that defining moment that just made you think, "Wow, this looks like me"?

Speaker 2: Um, I wish I could answer that. I don't know that I have a good answer. I think I, um, you know, I, as I was practicing law, I, um, you know, I put myself through law school and so, a- and I was doing legal work that didn't earn a ton of money, and so I needed just a part-time job. And at the time, I was r- into practicing yoga, and Lululemon just happened to be opening a store in Washington, DC, it was their first in that market. And, um, I'm tall, I'm 5'10, and they were the only company that I had heard of that made long yoga pants. And so it was before e-commerce and, and I just wound up going into their store and, and getting a part-time job. And, uh, so I was doing my legal work and working part-time at Lululemon as an educator, which is what Lululemon calls its sales folks, and I really fell in love with it. And I, I found that, um, it was exciting to see the business grow and build based on the relationships that we were making in the community. And they asked me if I wanted to come over full time, and I said yes. And before I know it, I just hit Lululemon at the right time, and it was really growing and scaling and, and I started to become really fascinated with the community side of the business, which is what a traditional company would call marketing. So I think, I, I think the, the moment was just that I felt very comfortable doing that kind of work, and now I've learned the ins and outs of actual, like, technical marketing along the way. But I think Lululemon was the real unlock for me.

Speaker 1: Wow, that's, that's great. Um-

Speaker 2: Yeah

Speaker 1: ... I love the idea of community and, yeah, let's, let's come onto that in a moment.

Speaker 2: Yeah.

Speaker 1: Um, so you've obviously had a, a pretty fascinating, varied career. Um, and along the way, you know, some of the businesses are very different to one another, but I think there's probably been a common thread as well. Uh-

Speaker 2: Yeah

Speaker 1: ... were there any particular defining moments that you've kind of taken on the p- on the path with you, uh, and you've brought to your practice now?

Speaker 2: Yeah, I mean, I think the... You know, it's, it's one thing to have a great experience in one organization and to feel like you're... For me, I speak for myself, like I'm really driving impact. And it's particularly fun when you're creating a category, you know, when, when somebody, uh, when it's like an unknown thing. People were not wearing black stretchy pants anywhere until Lululemon, um, created that category. And so I think what's kept me doing marketing work is that it feels like when it's done well, it's the one job where you're kind of paid to understand what people care about, and then be honest about it. I think I've always been most interested in the gap between what a company says and, and what a person needs, and I think really great marketing closes that gap, um, rather than just papers over it, which is why the Lululemon idea of education has kind of stuck with me and has been this anchor point through my career. So I think the defining moments, certainly being able to scale, um, being able to support scaling Lululemon was a huge defining moment for my career. I was there for 11 years. I really learned what marketing looked like while I was there. Um, bringing... At the beginning when I was in the US, we were just trying to g- get after Canada's business, right? We were trying to beat Canada's performance. And I don't know where Lululemon stands now, I'm not close to it anymore, but while I was there, we started to trounce Canada's business. So just that kind of, that excitement around, like, God, we were just five stores in the US, and now we're 250 stores in the US, and that kind of scale, of course, is really exciting. And then bringing Lululemon globally was also an exciting moment. Um, I think a big transition was from physical product to tech. I, I made the transition to Meetup, which is a community organizing platform. And same thread, just educating folks what, what Meetup was about and encouraging them to get offline and meet up in person over things they're passionate about. But that transition between, um, physical product and technical product was huge, and I stumbled a lot because I didn't understand, like, how product and engineering teams worked. Um, it was a completely different muscle for me. And then I think the biggest, the next biggest moment was into healthcare. Um, healthcare in the US is very complicated. We spend a lot of money. It's, there's a lot of problems to solve, and I think being able to apply, like, a direct-to-consumer mindset into a really opaque, traditionally opaque space has been pretty awesome.

Speaker 1: Yeah. And then community is one of the defining threads as well. It'd be great to understand your, your viewpoint on community or philosophy, as it were.

Speaker 2: Yeah. I guess I think about community as, um, more of a commitment and less as a channel. I think about whether or not the community would still show up if we never sold them anything. So one of the things that I think really set Lululemon apart is that the ethos was to give without expecting anything in return. And if it's not transactional- Um, sorry. If it's transactional, then people aren't showing up unless they get something. So, you know, if they're, if, if people still show up and we never sold them anything, if the answer is no to that, then it's an audience, not a community. And I think, um, that makes a big difference when things start to unravel because you need a community to really be able to support you, and things do unravel as a, as a brand set scales. You don't have visibility into what's happening in your factories. You're not sure what the QA process is. You make a misstep in PR. You need to have your community that kind of bolsters you and holds you up when things fall apart and, um, f- I view community as a commitment, not a channel.

Speaker 1: Mm. So it's about, um, how to describe it, paying the way forward, it feels like a, a good way of looking at it, and providing-

Speaker 2: Yeah

Speaker 1: ... value first.

Speaker 2: And I... That's right. A- and I guess I don't see, when you think about, one of the questions I often get is, especially now, because we're, we're tracking so much data, and on the growth side, through like direct return channels, it's so easy to see the impact. And for community, it's a much longer play, and I think that that is difficult to, um, invest in when all you wanna see is immediate return, immediate return. So many organizations are taking so much money in from VCs and PE firms, that the expectation is, well, we, we have to see an immediate return. And so it's tricky to strike the balance between, um, how do we make sure that we have that always-on engine really humming and that we're investing in our long-term brand health, which I consider a function of community.

Speaker 1: How do you reconcile that then with the expectations of the board? How do you present the value of community when it's a long, as you said, it's a long-term investment?

Speaker 2: Yeah. I mean, I, I g- you know, I think it's attention. Um, but I don't think they're incompatible. I see it more as a time horizon. So if community is the slowest sales motion, but the strongest one, I think trust really compounds. And the deals that start with, "I already know you, know you," like, they close differently. But I'm honest with the CEO and the board that some of the value won't trace neatly to a deal, so we watch leading signals like return attendance or referrals or how warm the first conversion is. So I'm not... Or sorry, how wa- how warm the first conversation is. So it's not to say that we're not tracking impact, it's just that the ROI, uh, is further up funnel and more on the leading side.

Speaker 1: Yeah. Um, when brands are looking at communities and perhaps starting to develop one of their own, um, or I guess look at the ecosystem that they're sat within anyway, um, what, what do you feel they get wrong in terms of mistakes, or po- perhaps it's just their outlook?

Speaker 2: Yeah. I think, um, the outlook is what's most important. I think a lot of organizations right now think of a community as transactional, and I think if you start off on that foot, you're, you're not setting up a real community. I think it's gotta be about, um, creating something that they feel that they can be a part of and that they are contributing to. Um, from there, you know, certainly on the execution side, there's 100 ways now that you can build a community bo- both offline and online, and I, and I really think that you need both. But it's the, um, outlook where I think people most stumble, because they're making it transactional.

Speaker 1: Yeah. And they wanna insert themselves into the conversation, um, or perhaps, I guess sh- you know, looking at it as an audience and, and wanting to broadcast. Would that be a classic mistake?

Speaker 2: I'm sorry, ask the question again, John.

Speaker 1: So, um, they perhaps look to insert themselves too heavily into the conversation, uh, or view the community more of a, as an audience, so perhaps kind of shouting out there-

Speaker 2: I think it's an audience

Speaker 1: As... Yeah

Speaker 2: Yeah. I think it's less about, I think it's less about inserting themselves into the conversation. Uh, you know, I, I think in some cases, brands should be a part of a conversation, but they have to be an authentic part of the conversation, and that doesn't happen when you're looking at the community as an audience. If you're looking at the community as, this is the group of people that's gonna help us hit our earnings target for Q3 or Q4, that's not the same thing as we're creating a space for people to come together and feel passionate about or something, and it doesn't need to be about the brand. In the case of Lululemon, for example, it was never about be passionate about Lululemon. It was be passionate about practicing yoga or going for a run or staying fit or getting healthy. And, and then Lululemon happened to be able to support that goal of that community. In the case of Sage, our community is really our caregivers, and what we're focused on is how do we make sure we're bui- we're building the best products to make caregiving easy for you. So what we're doing is just trying to listen for what's not working for you, because what any community really wants to feel is like that they're contributing to solving any given problem that they have or that they're able to come together over shared interests. We're not looking to the caregivers like, "Hey, can you help us hit our targets?" That's a different thing altogether.

Speaker 1: Yeah. I, I often look at community as w- what I'd call the three Rs, so relationships, build relationships with people. From there, that builds reputation and ob- obviously trust. Uh, and then-

Speaker 2: Yeah

Speaker 1: ... revenue comes, comes downstream of that, that's, uh, you know, attributable to those actions.

Speaker 2: I think that's right, and I think a lot about, um, you know, there's this balance between brand versus demand, and I think that that's a false choice. I think the dema- the demand generation is harvesting, and, and if you're only harvesting and you, like, you kind of eventually run out of good soil, right? And then when-

Speaker 1: Mm

Speaker 2: ... short-term pressure hits, you really have to, like, protect that brand investment and make it accountable by trying Like tying it to things that we can see. So the community is the thing that really keeps that soil arable and makes sure that we have the ability to harvest.

Speaker 1: Yeah, I totally agree. I mean, I, I see community building as brand exercise, frankly. I mean, clearly is.

Speaker 2: Yeah.

Speaker 1: Um, and-

Speaker 2: Agree

Speaker 1: ... without brand, you, you can't generate demand anyway. Um, and-

Speaker 2: It's interesting though that the, that the investment, you know, like that the, our investors... What, what do you think it is that makes it so difficult for the folks that are support our organizations to invest in the long-term health of a brand? Like, what are you, what are you hearing about that?

Speaker 1: I think it's a mix of things. I think it's habitual, frankly. Um-

Speaker 2: Yeah

Speaker 1: ... the, in the past, money has been cheap. You know, let's be honest, you can refinance, obviously finance your debt book, et cetera. Um-

Speaker 2: Yeah

Speaker 1: ... and plow that money into short-term demand generation. Um, I feel that CFOs, it's easy for a CFO to understand, hey, we put some money in here, we generate X number of leads, we approach them in such a way, and the engine spits out X amount of revenue. So it's quantifiable. You know, there's a, a science behind that. Um-

Speaker 2: Yeah

Speaker 1: ... but I truly believe it comes at the detriment of the 95%. So you might say, oh, 5% are in market at this given time, and frankly, I believe it's less than that, uh, for B2B businesses. Uh, okay, well, let's focus on the 5%. Yeah. The problem there is the detriment of the, the 95, right? Who will come into market-

Speaker 2: Agree

Speaker 1: ... or potentially come into market further down the line. Um, people need to find a equilibrium, of course, um, 'cause you can't sacrifice one for the other. Um, it would be really interesting to understand what your stance is on that. How do you find that, that balance, um, rather than going too far in one, one direction or, or not far enough in another?

Speaker 2: Yeah, that's a really good question. I mean, I, I 100% agree with you that most buyers aren't in market at any given moment. So you, so if you only show up when they're ready to buy, you're competing on price and speed. And I think the brands that people really care about are the ones they already trusted before they need anything. In terms of like how I think about balancing early brand investment with demand generation, I think it depends on, um, the size of any given organization and like the point at which they're operating. For us at Sage now, um, we're still very much in the brand-building business, so we're, we're an unknown entity, um, in a smaller market, right? So, so we're really heavily invested right now in building up our brand and our brand recognition. Uh, so right now it's about 60/40. Um, but I imagine that that will shift. I think the harder piece is not at the early stages, it's at the later stages when you hold-

Speaker 1: Mm-hmm

Speaker 2: ... on to, um, the importance of brand, not just for like converting campaigns, but real brand work that might see, that might only track longer leading indicators of success.

Speaker 1: Yeah. One of the things that I, I truly believe as well is that we're going through a groundswell at, at this point in time in terms of reinvestment in brand and the importance of brand building. Uh, and-

Speaker 2: Yeah

Speaker 1: ... I believe that that's fueled by AI, um-

Speaker 2: Yep

Speaker 1: ... and needing to be there, needing to get the citations, um, needing to shift budget to brilliant storytelling, to content creation, and so on as the customer journey is, is fundamentally changing. So that's, that's one part of it. But also the fact, and I'm gonna use the John Rudzinski quote 'cause I love it, where he-

Speaker 2: Mm

Speaker 1: ... he says, "Brand is the engine of the world." And I, I truly believe that. So-

Speaker 2: Yeah

Speaker 1: ... um, at the point of somebody thinking about a shortlist, you're already there because, you know, you, you, you're already front of mind from that-

Speaker 2: That's right

Speaker 1: ... brand investment.

Speaker 2: And I think that... I think that's right. And I think one of the interest- there's so many interesting things that are, that are shifting with AI, but one of the areas that I'm hopeful with is that, you know, when everyone can generate content, content stops being the advantage, which is I think where we've been for the past, you know, at least five years or so. And what's left is what really can't be generated, so it's proprietary data, it feels like it's a real point of view, um, and relationships and taste, and that feels like a pivot to where a CMO might have been 15 years ago, 20 years ago. And that, you know, I think that that's been that kind of relationship perspective, the taste, the way we use data. Um, we haven't really been able to exercise those muscles over the past 10 years or so because of AI really coming to the front. But now that it's here, it feels like, okay, well, we get to double down on those things that are uniquely human, um, and see what you can do with it.

Speaker 1: Yeah. Um, I look at a lot of AI content, and frankly, if I pick up a white paper or a report or something and I, I read the first few paragraphs or the exec sum and it's, and it sniffs of AI, then I don't want to read it.

Speaker 2: Stop reading it.

Speaker 1: Yeah.

Speaker 2: Of course. Yeah.

Speaker 1: Um-

Speaker 2: Yeah

Speaker 1: ... whereas-

Speaker 2: I mean, and you can tell right away. I do think that the struggle there, and we face this even at, at Sage, even though I'm, I'm aware that people know that it's AI and, like, nobody wants to read it, is just the amount of the volume, the pressure of, like, the volume that you have to put out to keep this, like, always on engine running, but to still make space for these meaningful brand moments. It's hard to do both well.

Speaker 1: Yeah. I f- I, I actually feel that it can be done well, but you need the human-

Speaker 2: Yeah

Speaker 1: ... expert, um, guiding over it, and it's not necessarily a task for a, a junior person who's still learning the ropes. Um, you need somebody who's, uh, had maybe 20 years experience or perhaps has come from an analyst business, um, that, uh, aligns with the market that, that you're in. Um-

Speaker 2: Yeah

Speaker 1: ... but you n- you really do need a high degree of human expertise, uh, and yeah, and manual intervention as well.

Speaker 2: Yeah. Agree.

Speaker 1: Um, and, uh, I think what comes across is, you know, there is a lot of content out there, and there's a lot more content. And the... I guess the, uh, the bottom has become the average as it were. You know, it's, it's kind of risen up. Uh-

Speaker 2: Yep

Speaker 1: ... um, but it also means that the, if you think of that as the floor, the ceiling has, has risen as well in terms of great quality content being the ceiling and, and, and kind of rising to the top.

Speaker 2: Yeah

Speaker 1: ... uh, and what people are looking for at this point in time.

Speaker 2: I think it has, and we've been working really hard at, at Sage to figure out, um... 'cause for me, it's mostly about the human storytelling from a content perspective. Everybody says that, of course, right? But sometimes it's difficult to identify and to build the kinds of relationships that you need with your community to actually draw those stories out. It's a big investment in time. Uh, but that's, that I think is a great differentiator for an organization or a brand if they can figure out how to really connect with their communities and pull those stories through.

Speaker 1: Yeah. Um, I also believe in putting a, a face to a business as well, and I think that works really well. Um, I had a great conversation with, um, Bain, obviously the consultancy company, last Tuesday. Um, and what they're looking to do is to, I guess, unlock the knowledge within the business a- and externalize it through the experts that they have, the consultants that they have, various others, um, and use that as relationship development and, I don't really wanna call it thought leadership. Uh, it kind of goes beyond thought leadership.

Speaker 2: Yeah. It's interesting. I have this, uh... At Lululemon, I had a mentor. His name is Duke Stump, and he, he had a very Lululemon way of saying it, which was like this, kind of this g- this idea of a great lover, which is how I think about thought leadership. Like, nobody ever tells... Nobody ever talks about themselves as a great lover. You really need somebody else to say it about you, and I think that that's what thought leadership at its fundamental is about, is like you need other people speaking about you on your behalf, and it needs to come across as authentic. To your point, you can... When, when it's a spade, uh, paid sponsorship, you know, I look at all these organizations that have all these awards, it's like it's all pay-to-play. You have to be able to really develop relationships and have people say meaningful things about you, and that takes an investment. At Sage just recently, we hosted something called Sage Shift, which was a caregiver summit, and we flew 150 caregivers to New York. In some cases, some of them have never been on a plane. And they're not the buyers, right? They're not the economic buyers, but they're our users. They're the ones that use our product. So we flew them all to New York and, um, with the idea that we would learn from them what they need from a product in order to be more successful at their job. If they're great at their job, then older adults get the care that they need. So it's important to us that we're connecting with the caregivers. And at the end of those two days, we had this really great kind of product forum and feedback session, and we got to get to know the caregivers a lot more and really understand them better. But at the end of that, for two weeks they've been talking about Sage, of course, right? Because we created this experience for them, and that is the kind of, um, thought leadership that I think really helps a brand stand out as like, hey, this group of people is authentically speaking about this brand and what the value that it adds. That's a huge investment, but you can buy that kind of thought leadership.

Speaker 1: Yeah. That, that, that's it. I, I totally agree. And that, that sort of leads me to thinking about brand as utility as well-

Speaker 2: Yeah

Speaker 1: ... and showing up, how you show up, how you're useful in people's lives, um, and the utility that you provide as, as a, as a brand. And, and then that g- that gains the, uh, the emotional buy-in and, you know, um, and the endearment of the community that you service.

Speaker 2: I love it. I, I mean, you know, I, I started... I hadn't really had the, um, professional maturity at Lululemon to really understand what it was that we were doing, like that we were a utility. I think I saw that more when I got to Meetup, and then when I got to Galileo in the healthcare space, and certainly now at Sage. I love it because it changes the question from how do we sell more to how do we become part of how the work gets done? And in the case of Sage, um, we kind of earn a place in someone's day, and I think that that is indispensable.

Speaker 1: I love the idea of-

Speaker 2: The strongest-

Speaker 1: Yeah

Speaker 2: Yeah, go ahead please

Speaker 1: ... of earning a place in someone's... I love that language. The ear- the earning a place in someone's day is fantastic.

Speaker 2: Yeah, I mean, I think if you can make someone feel more capable, um, that's where you can't imagine living without. And, and in our case it's capable because they're doing their jobs, but I don't know that I can live without Uber, right? Like, they have earned a place in my day. Um, and I think that from a B2B perspective, uh, especially in our case with Sage, it really makes a big difference.

Speaker 1: Yeah. I mean, U- Uber are... Well, actually, they're a client of mine, but, uh, they're in many categories-

Speaker 2: They are, yeah

Speaker 1: ... as well. So I mean, they, you obviously have health, you've got the restaurants, you've got the rides.

Speaker 1: You know, et cetera, et cetera, et cetera. Um, and-

Speaker 2: It's also interesting with Uber to think about-

Speaker 1: I couldn't live without them

Speaker 2: ... like how they...

Speaker 2: Yeah, you can't live without them. And it's interesting to think about how they... Did they know that they would expand into all of those areas when they started, or did they just see opportunity and then start to like build small into the other categories? How did that operate?

Speaker 1: I don't know, and-

Speaker 2: Yeah

Speaker 1: ... I wouldn't be able to comment on it, but, uh, I'm gonna a- I'm gonna assume that they had a purpose to create one thing They probably had in mind that their, you know, it's like any business, right? Um, that there's always adjacent products or adjacent areas that, you know, are, are, are natural to better move into.

Speaker 2: Yeah.

Speaker 1: Um, so I imagine that along the way that they s- they obviously saw the opportunity, um, once they had the, the, you know, the, the, the base in place. I mean, at the end of the day, every business starts on day one. You know-

Speaker 2: That's right

Speaker 1: ... day, day one of a startup, there's no way that you could be-

Speaker 1: ... even imagining the scale that they've achieved and-

Speaker 2: No, you can't imagine it

Speaker 1: ... yeah, and the areas and the lines of business that, um, that they've successfully built and, and developed over time.

Speaker 2: Yeah. It's exciting.

Speaker 1: Um, in terms of... I'm trying to think about it. Yeah, in terms of sort of teams and, and, you know, kind of building team within the business, what's your outlook? You know, how, how do you go about, um, building and developing a, a great culture within your company?

Speaker 2: Yeah. Um, I think most of it, I guess mostly I'm thinking about... It's interesting 'cause, because AI is moving so quickly, I'm hesitating because I, I felt confident about what that looked like five years ago, but now I don't know if I know what it looks like. I think I'm trying to keep the teams as agile as possible so that we can pivot and change directions if we need to. I think regardless of the makeup of the team, whether you're hiring gener- why- whether you're hiring generalists or, um, subject matter experts, I think the most important piece is that they are accountable and that they feel ownership over the work that they're building. Um, from my leadership style in particular, I'm not someone who, uh, wants to be in all the details or the weeds. I want a, like, functional, strong readout of what's working well and what's not working well, and so mostly I'm looking for folks that are really willing to hustle and get their hands dirty. And, and in terms of, like, the culture of the team, and, and we take this from Lululemon, I take this from Lululemon, is just this, uh, real candor and feedback that goes both ways. Um, I think we need to be ensuring that, uh, we're talking to each other and building relationships with one another. And I think especially in a remote first world now, um, that can be more complicated, uh, where it's different being in person with one another than it is being over video. And I think you really need to build relationships with one another in order to be able to have honest and candid feedback, and you need the honest and candid feedback in order to, to scale an organization quickly. So yeah, mostly I'm looking for folks who I can build a rapport with so that we can get to the work of, like, doing the work.

Speaker 1: Yeah. Um, yeah, one thing I, that I'm concerned about is the, the entry level jobs being automated, uh, and the raft of new people coming into a business who, you know, f- and, and, and the development path for them, who are gonna become, you know, the, the future leaders of a company. Um-

Speaker 2: I think about it a lot

Speaker 1: ... I understand that businesses have-

Speaker 2: Yeah.

Speaker 1: Yeah, I understand that businesses, um, have to look for efficiencies, um, cost savings, become more profitable, et cetera, um, but it's very hard, isn't it, to, to get that, to get that balance right? Do you feel that companies have rushed in too quickly to, um, to automate, to put the AIs in, without necessarily addressing some of the challenges that might come along the line, or perhaps, in fact, looking at their business model first, uh, which I believe should be the starting point, and then thinking about, well, how do we restructure and then how are we gonna start transforming?

Speaker 2: I think we're all rushing into it very quickly and, um, potentially making team structural decisions that, um, aren't supported by enough data or information. I also think that we're gonna find... Like, succession planning is really tricky. When you're not hiring people in, in the kind of ground floor roles where they can't learn from their mentors and their colleagues how to do this, for example, the VP of growth role or the CMO role, um, there's no bench, right? And so, um, we're automating all of these junior roles and thinking, "Well, AI can do it." And to a certain extent, there's efficiencies to be gained, of course, but two things. One, I think you... We all can see slop right away, which is mostly on the AI side, and we need to be able to bring a human perspective to that work and, and lots of times it would be the junior roles that would be doing that. And, or to your point, someone senior who has the bandwidth, so needs a team underneath them. And also, we need benches. We need to be able to, um, teams scale up and they scale down and, and when, when, when roles shift around, you need to be able to point to existing team members and say, like, "Hey, can you pick this up?" And if folks aren't being developed from a career perspective internally, then we don't have that bench, and I think it puts the organization at a real disadvantage.

Speaker 1: Yeah. Within your business, does AI, or do you have an, an owner, as it were, for AI? Do they sit in tech or do you have people at departmental level?

Speaker 2: Yeah. We have, uh, because we are in an AI business, our, uh, big, a large portion of what we, what we sell is AI, meaning we are doing, in senior living communities and skilled nursing facilities, w- our, our suite, our products, our, our platform, one of the areas is fall management and fall detection, which uses AI. And so- We have... It sits mostly in the product and tech team, but of course, all teams right now are using AI to gain efficiencies. There's a difference between product development on the AC- AI side and us using Claude or whatever it might be to help us gain efficiencies. So we use it in two different ways.

Speaker 1: Yeah. And actually, let's- let's just dig into your product slightly as well. So-

Speaker 2: Yeah

Speaker 1: ... that- that was kind of interesting. You're saying that identifies files, you know, et cetera. What does that look like? And, um, so that's the external view. But it sounds-

Speaker 2: Yeah

Speaker 1: ... like you- you utilize some of that functionality internally within your practice and w- within your business as well.

Speaker 2: I wouldn't say that we use the A- the function... The- the AI that we're selling is not something that we use internally. So we are... We sell the hardware and software for these communities, and, um, we use AI in our product experience. But internally, you know, of course, we use the- the data that- that the software and the hardware collects in these communities to make our products better and to serve up more insights to our clients. Uh, but when on the operating side, we're not using our AI platform to, for example, on the marketing side, we use different tools.

Speaker 1: Yeah. Cool. Um, and in terms of the CMO, the- the CMO role, uh-

Speaker 2: Yeah

Speaker 1: ... how do you see that changing? Do you see the CMO, um, as being the leader who's gonna help take the business through the- the next wave of transformation, which is clearly AI, um, or, um, yeah, or yeah, I'm just wondering how you're seeing it. So I had a conversation in CAM, for instance, with, uh, a senior marketer, and she was saying to me, "Well, I'm being looked at as the chief, uh, marketing technology, strategy, creative," you know, et cetera, et cetera, et cetera, "officer."

Speaker 2: Yeah.

Speaker 1: And that doesn't exist in one person. You know? That's multiple people. But-

Speaker 2: Yeah

Speaker 1: ... but it is the perception of- of the- of the board at this point in time that, you know, she was dealing with within her particular business. Um, so yeah-

Speaker 2: Yeah

Speaker 1: ... how do you see the CMO role shape-shifting, changing, and do you believe that the CMO, um, will be the individual or perhaps collaboratively with others that helps the- the transformation of the company, given the proximity to the, you know, the end user or the customer?

Speaker 2: Yeah, I mean, I think it's going to be collaborative. I do think that the role itself, and who knows, um, of course, what- what it would be called or how it might evolve, I think we're all in for a shakeup over the next five to 10 years. But I- I think this function moves from k- kind of owning the messaging to really owning trust, and it's... I think it's gonna be less about production and more about judgment and taste. I think it'll be closer to product and data, uh, because the customer experience, like, really is the marketing, and I, uh, certainly right now, I'm accountable for both revenue and reputation, and I think that will continue to be the case in the future.

Speaker 1: Yeah. Um, and I'm just, I'm just mindful of time, so just-

Speaker 2: Yeah

Speaker 1: ... towards sort of wrap-up, as it were, I'm just gonna ask you a couple of quick fire questions to start with. But, um-

Speaker 2: Sure

Speaker 1: ... are there any brands out there that you, or businesses, that you particularly admire at this point in time? Uh, it could be how they- they show out, how they're presenting themselves, perhaps the actions that they take.

Speaker 2: Yeah, it's a great question. I mean, always and forever Patagonia. I think it's interesting they, um... I haven't heard much from them lately, so it's interest- I wonder what they're kind of up to over there. My girlfriend is running a- a similar brand called Finisterre, actually out of your hometown. Um, I think that they do a really interesting job in having a strong brand ethos. Um, and then on the tech side, I'm really interested in what Ramp is doing. It seems so small and kind of inconsequential, but talk about utility. Um, they've done an incredible job of making something that is laborious and awful really delightful for people. And so I feel really excited about what they're building over there.

Speaker 1: Yeah. I, I totally agree. Love Ramp. Um, love Patagonia.

Speaker 2: Yeah.

Speaker 1: Um, and I'm not familiar with the other one, so I'm gonna have to, uh, I'm just gonna have to go take a look.

Speaker 2: Yeah, Finisterre.

Speaker 1: Well-

Speaker 2: They do... They're like a-

Speaker 1: Yeah

Speaker 2: ... they're a, um, co- similar to Patagonia, more in the surfing world, um, out of Cornwall, but they're great.

Speaker 1: Wow. Sounds great. Um-

Speaker 2: Yeah

Speaker 1: ... next, in terms of staying sharp and, you know, and- and how to describe it, yeah, in- in terms of keeping yourself sharp, are there any sort of go-to resources for yourself? Uh, or perhaps it's just a place that you like to go to that inspires you, that helps free up your thinking.

Speaker 2: Yeah. I think a few things. One, uh, it's like, it's hard, there's so much out, so much incredible content out there now, and resources out there now that it can kind of feel overwhelming. I have some standbys. I follow Emily Kramer to keep in touch with technically, like, where I need to be improving and growing on the B2B side. I really like Chris Dentons. Um, Scan Club, I like them quite a bit. Um, I like Foster Kramer quite a bit. So in terms of, like, consuming content, that's where I, where I like to focus. And then I just got back, in terms of, like, recharging my creativity, I just got back from a couple of days in Spain a- and did some art museums, and I think that I had forgotten I have so much access here in New York. Um, I used to try to go quite a bit, and I kind of fell off it. You know, I got busy and, and then th- this past couple of days I was like, "God, I forgot that I need to feel recharged creatively," and- and certainly, like, being in the museums in any city that you're in, I think do a good job of that.

Speaker 1: Yeah, I love that. So it's, it's all about input, right? Um, learning, input, uh, and then you have the, the, in the, in-the-shower moment, as it were.

Speaker 2: Yeah, it's just like that curiosity. I'm getting all these signals, and then suddenly I'm like, "I have an idea for Sage," and, um-

Speaker 1: Yeah

Speaker 2: ... it's important to keep those sharp.

Speaker 1: Yeah. Love it. Um, and lastly, advice that you'd provide to a- a younger individual who's looking at the world of perhaps tech, uh-

Speaker 2: Mm

Speaker 1: ... marketing. Um, what advice would you provide them at an early stage of a career, or perhaps they're, you know, they're just looking to enter similar world to yourself?

Speaker 2: I had a girlfriend, um, whose daughter reached out to me 'cause she's in law school, and she's panicking about, like, "I don't know what I wanna do. I'm not..." You know, it's when, when you have everything ahead of you, it's hard to f- it's hard... You feel like you have to make a choice. So I guess the advice that I gave her, though I don't feel particularly qualified for it , is, um, just find something you like doing. Like, don't worry so much about whether you can make a career out of it or whether you're gonna be a CMO because of it or, um, whether you feel like you can buy a place in New York City by doing it. It's like j- you're gonna be excellent at something that you enjoy. For Lululemon, I was folding pants. I just liked the company and the organization, and, and so I was able to do good work with them. I think it's like, just find something you enjoy and you'll find your path.

Speaker 1: Yeah. No, I, I totally agree. I mean, at the end of the day, yeah, um, happiness has gotta come first before performance, right?

Speaker 2: Like, what are we doing here? You spend a lot of time at work. Yeah just like-

Speaker 1: Yeah

Speaker 2: ... find something you like.

Speaker 1: Brilliant. Look, it's been a fantastic conversation today. Thank you so much for-

Speaker 2: Really nice meeting you

Speaker 1: ... for joining me on the show. Really enjoyed it.

Speaker 2: Yeah. Thank you, John. I've enjoyed it. Okay. Be well.

Speaker 1: You're, you're welcome.

The Rewrite

Stay close to the conversation.

The conversations and intelligence worth knowing about.

About the guest

Carolyn Manning

Chief Marketing Officer, Sage · Season 7, Episode 170

Carolyn Manning is Chief Marketing Officer at Sage, which builds hardware and software, including AI fall detection, for senior living communities and skilled nursing facilities. She is known for building community-led brands across retail, technology and healthcare, with a career that began in law and took off at Lululemon.

Read the interview Full profile LinkedIn (opens in a new tab)

Share