Episode 171 · Season 7 · ·

Better Than Default

Emily Heyward, Co-founder and CEO of Red Antler, on why brand value is only ever comparative, relevance has to be earned again every year, and no category is safe from disruption.

Emily Heyward, Co-founder and CEO, Red Antler. In conversation with John Horsley.

Read the interview
Share
Emily Heyward, Co-founder and CEO at Red Antler
Emily Heyward, Red Antler

Better Than Default

0:0042:00

Nineteen years building Red Antler, from launching pre-launch startups to telling new-to-the-world stories for businesses at the highest stakes moments. Heyward argues that in an era where everyone claims AI and everyone can prompt a decent website, brand value is only ever comparative, and the job is to be better than the other guy.

Heyward traces her pull towards the business to a childhood spent immersed in pop culture, television and magazines, cutting out ads she liked and hanging them on her walls. The road into advertising was, she says, a wandering one, but she was drawn fast to a discipline that converged creativity with thinking hard about people and what makes them tick. In 2007 she co-founded Red Antler, whose early focus was launching new businesses into the world, often pre-launch startups. That remains part of the work, but the company now serves businesses of every scale and industry. Under Red Antler Group she has built a media arm called Fat Earth and spun off Wildfruit, which focuses on investor decks, and she points to clients including Ramp, the conversational shopping platform Daydream, the AI scent company Osmo and the labneh brand Bezi.

In this conversation with host John Horsley, Heyward argues that AI has become as meaningless a word as tech or dot-com, and that throwing it into a deck is not a story. She makes the case that the only value of a brand is comparative, that an addiction to the measurable 5% quietly erodes the 95, and that leaders have to keep refilling the goodwill of their audience before it runs out. She is clear that there is still room for human expertise, for curation and for physical retail, and blunt that the rush to cut entry-level jobs is storing up a talent gap. Be better than the other guy, or do not bother.

Agencies have a similar model. How do you see them evolving under AI?

“We just have to be better than the other guy.”

When she launched Red Antler there was a site called 99designs where you could buy a logo for 99 dollars, and none of those businesses are still around to tell the tale unless they rebranded, because cheap, bad design has always been available. Generative AI is getting really good, but the only value of a brand is comparative; there is no intrinsic value, they are not making art, they just have to be better than the other guy. If everybody can prompt a good-looking website, it will not be the website that helps businesses win. Their job is to help businesses win.

Every company claims to be AI-powered. How do you help clients differentiate?

“I think that AI has become synonymous with tech, which is an equally meaningless word.”

She agrees completely: everybody is throwing AI into the deck to increase valuations and interest. AI has become synonymous with tech, which is an equally meaningless word, like the businesses that put dot-com in their name in an earlier era. The work is to help businesses tell a story that may incorporate AI but transcends it, speaking to the greater value they offer and why they matter more than others claiming to do the same thing.

Is there a common thing businesses get wrong reaching customers?

“You've got to, like, refill the goodwill coffer, if you will”

These days there is an understandable but mistaken addiction to data. Because certain activities give an immediate return, it becomes hard to justify spend elsewhere, even for established businesses. Performance marketing is important, but without investment in other activity there is an inevitable erosion over time. You are only chasing the 5%; you cannot neglect the 95. You have to refill the goodwill coffer with your audience or it runs out.

From Business of Marketing

Put yourself forward or recommend a guest for us to consider.

Request an interview →

So much of your work is about emotion. Where does it sit when people buy through an assistant?

“I don't think your job ends with the first purchase.”

It varies by category, but the engine still relies on human input, so the question is how much emotion has already been established to make you the soap ChatGPT recommends. The line between product and brand is very blurry, and a lot of brand-building is what happens once the product is in someone's hands: the experience, the packaging, the scent. Even if a bot got it into your home, the job is to remind them you exist. Your job does not end with the first purchase; in some ways that is where it starts.

What is your take on synthetic data?

“I don't trust it yet.”

She does not trust it yet. She is very interested in the space because consumer research is incredibly important and quicker, accurate reads would be invaluable, but she is not sure they are there. Red Antler does the opposite: an AI moderator that interviews real humans, bringing efficiency while still talking to real people. It is cheaper and faster for quick reads, with a human moderator kept for in-depth research.

Never miss an episode. Follow Business of Marketing.

Read the full transcript

Lightly edited for readability

Speaker 1: Welcome to Business Marketing. My name's John Horsley, I'm the host of the show today. I'm absolutely delighted p- to be joined by Emily Heyward, who is CEO at Red Antler. Welcome to the show.

Speaker 2: Thank you so much for having me. I'm thrilled to be here.

Speaker 1: Tell me this, what got you into our world in the first instance? So going back to the, the younger you, as it were.

Speaker 2: Wow, way back. Um, so I, from a very young age, was always really interested in pop culture. You know, loved TV, loved magazines. That was the era I grew up in. I used to cut out ads that I liked and hang them on my walls, and always wanted to do something that got me closer to that world, um, thinking about sort of trends and fashion and, like, what was in, what was out. Um, that was always really where my interests lay. And in terms of advertising specifically, it was a little bit of a wandering road, but didn't take me long to discover this industry, and I think that I was immediately drawn to it because of how it sort of converged creativity with really thinking about people-

Speaker 1: Mm

Speaker 2: ... and what makes them tick. And I think that the, the combination of those two things was what fascinated me.

Speaker 1: Yeah. And tell me a little bit about Red Antler, and also for those who are unaware, what's your reason for existence?

Speaker 2: So I started Red Antler with my co-founder in 2007, so we're 19 years old. In the early days, our focus was launching new businesses into the world. We worked with a lot of pre-launch startups. That's still a big part of who we are today, and we still work with pre-launch startups, but we now work with businesses of all scales and sizes. I think that our reason for being is really to tell new-to-the-world stories at the highest stakes moments.

Speaker 1: Hm. And the, you know, the, the startups, as it were, let's, let's talk about them to start with. How's the playbook changed? How's that altered over that period of time?

Speaker 2: I think that when we started Red Antler, we had an advantage in that there wasn't a whole lot of conversation happening about how important it was to build a brand from the beginning. So just by showing up with, like, a well-conceived, strategic, beautifully executed brand, businesses had an advantage. That is not true anymore .

Speaker 1: Sure.

Speaker 2: Everybody recognizes, like, they need to look good and they need to have their story down. So I think it's gotten far more competitive. I would also just say the pressure on businesses from the beginning to show up across a myriad of channels is much greater.

Speaker 1: Yeah.

Speaker 2: Um, and they really need to be thinking from day one about just, like, an insane amount of content and storytelling to kinda keep fueling those engines.

Speaker 1: Yeah. And what, what types of businesses were you working with? Are they SaaS? Are they other types of businesses?

Speaker 2: Honestly, we work across every industry.

Speaker 1: Okay.

Speaker 2: I think that we became known for some of our big successes in the world of, like, direct-to-consumer consumer brands, but we've always been really well diversified, and for us it's more about a moment in time. So that might be pre-launch or that might be a pivotal moment where a business comes to us needing to evolve their brand or even launch a campaign, 'cause we have an advertising team-

Speaker 1: Mm

Speaker 2: ... because the stakes have changed, and they need to tell a new story in order to reach their next stage of growth. So-

Speaker 1: Yeah

Speaker 2: ... more of our business now is with companies that are already in market, but we do work with a lot of startups, whether they're pre-launch or later stage.

Speaker 1: Yeah. And pre-launch, are you helping them market themselves for investment? You know-

Speaker 2: Sometimes

Speaker 1: ... how, how are you helping them?

Speaker 2: Yeah, I mean, I think that when a business comes to us, they're certainly planning to fundraise, if not already-

Speaker 1: Sure

Speaker 2: ... fundraising.

Speaker 1: Yes.

Speaker 2: Um, you know, I think a tiny mom-and-pop shop, it probably wouldn't make sense for them to hire us if they're not really looking to reach-

Speaker 1: Mm

Speaker 2: ... that level of scale. We actually s- spun off a company that specializes in investor decks specifically, called Wildfruit, so they really help with that fundraise moment. But for us, the work we do absolutely helps with fundraising because it is about solidifying, like, how do you tell the story of why this business matters?

Speaker 1: Yeah. Yeah. I mean, it's making me think that the, the moat, as it were, is fundamentally changed or changing. And so certainly in terms of what investors are looking at at this point in time and why, um, things that were dis- defensible before are less defensible now. Um, fungible is probably a good term. Uh, things can easily be replicated and copied, certainly in the world of AI. Um, yeah, how, how are you working with your clients in this sort of ever-changing world?

Speaker 2: Yeah, I mean, I think you're right. I definitely think that maybe different things are now dependable.

Speaker 1: Mm.

Speaker 2: Um, you know, in the world of consumer, the fundraising landscape has changed so much, and I think with good reason. I actually think there was an era in which consumer businesses were raising too much money, and it put undue pressure, and it led a lot of them to lower their standards and, and not scale successfully. Um, but what we're, we're also working with, you know, a ton of AI businesses now, as I'm sure you would imagine.

Speaker 1: Sure.

Speaker 2: You know, many of our clients are AI businesses, and they're having no trouble fundraising right now.

Speaker 1: Mm. Um, actually, I'm gonna say this. So yeah, most businesses are AI businesses now, right?

Speaker 2: Sure.

Speaker 1: Yeah, you're a tech company, you've- you know, you're AI-powered. You look at all the ad techs last year, they're all saying they're AI-powered. I'm looking at them now thinking, "Okay, what's the difference between them? They're all AI-powered."

Speaker 2: Sure.

Speaker 1: How do, how do you help your clients differentiate themselves within a marketplace where all companies are claiming to be a, an AI business?

Speaker 2: Uh, first of all, 100% agree with you, and I think that we're at a moment in time where everybody's just, like, throwing AI into the deck and into the story, you know, to increase their valuations and increase interest. We are trying to help the businesses we work with think past this moment in time.

Speaker 1: Mm.

Speaker 2: I think that AI has become synonymous with tech, which is an equally meaningless word.

Speaker 1: Yeah, or digital.

Speaker 2: And I think... Yeah. It's like the businesses that-

Speaker 1: Yeah

Speaker 2: ... put .com in their name at a certain era now that feels so dated.

Speaker 1: Mm.

Speaker 2: So I think that we are trying to help businesses tell a story that m- may very well incorporate AI, but it also needs to transcend it and speak to, like, the greater value that they're offering and, and why they matter more than other businesses that might seem to be claiming to do the same thing.

Speaker 1: Yeah. Can you give a, a kind of a real-life example, perhaps, uh, a number of clients or a, a client that you're working with and- How you may have, uh, helped them successfully?

Speaker 2: Yeah, I mean, I think Ramp, which has been an unbelievably successful client of ours, is a great example of this, that when they first came to us, you know, they were recently in market. They were already seeing incredible traction, but I do think that they recognized that they needed to solidify their narrative to really break through and, and get the attention of CFOs that are just being bombarded with, like, platforms and credit cards and, like, all these SaaS tools that are trying to, you know, get their business.

Speaker 1: Mm.

Speaker 2: And I think we were able to help them in those early days really think about telling a story of, like, the values of the businesses that end up using Ramp, and sort of positioning it as the platform that's for the smart, modern business leader that isn't just looking to, like, rack up points, but rather think about more visibility, more control. You know, sort of speaking directly to that CFO and what they care about in a way that no one else in the space was doing.

Speaker 1: Sure. That's, that's really cool. Um, I'm thinking about AI and how it removes part of the value that a business presents. Yeah? So whether it's consultancy businesses, they put lots of people into companies. Perhaps you need slightly less of those people in the companies. Perhaps they're helping them with a AI transformation that maybe replaces them. Uh, thinking about retail, that's probably a really good example. Um, different elements of retail will clearly be removed and will vanish, uh, as we move from, I guess, business to agent, and then agent to agent. Um, what's your viewpoint on, on that and, and how, um, business models need to fundamentally evolve, otherwise those companies will face a, a distinction... uh, extinction event?

Speaker 2: Yeah, I mean, look, I think that there's no question this is a watershed moment, and I would be naive to be like, "Nothing's gonna change," right?

Speaker 1: Mm.

Speaker 2: Everything's already changing. I do think that's a multi-layered question.

Speaker 1: Of course.

Speaker 2: And I'll try to attack it piece by piece. I think in terms of retail, I think we're already at a place where if people just want, like, a completely utilitarian retail experience, they can get it, right? Like, they can go to Google. It works very, very well. The Google algor- algorithm is excellent. And just, like, put in what they want. Or Amazon equally, right? But we still find that the retail experiences that are really able to build an experience are able to draw business away from Google Shop and from Amazon, right?

Speaker 1: Yeah.

Speaker 2: I mean, we helped launch a conversational AI shopping platform called Daydream that, you know, theoretically they're competing with Google, but what they're bringing to the table is, like, a fashion sensibility and a model that's specifically designed for people who care about clothes and love clothes and care about brands.

Speaker 1: Mm.

Speaker 2: And that's a very different experience than just being in, like, a completely neutral environment. So I think that there's still gonna always be room to build brands that connect with people. You're just gonna have to find new ways in, different ways to do it.

Speaker 1: Yeah. So what we're also talking about there is the, the customer journey, right? And, and buying behavior fundamentally changing. How have you seen that evolve?

Speaker 2: Yeah, I mean, I think that it, it is certainly starting to be the case that people are gonna, you know, go right into their LLM and, like, ask for a recommendation, right? And I'm not a AEO expert, but w- where are those recommendations pulling from? They're pulling from Reddit. They're pulling from Google reviews. They're pulling from articles, right?

Speaker 1: Sure.

Speaker 2: They're pulling from press mentions, which again, are all generated by quality, by, you know, people telling their friends, by, you know, consumer love. So it might show up in a different way, but I think the fundamentals still matter a whole lot.

Speaker 1: Yeah. So do you feel that that is shifting the way that brands behave? Um, shifting businesses towards storytelling?

Speaker 2: Definitely. And I think that even before the past couple years where, like, AI is all anyone's talking about, I would say that, like, the e-com website as the be all, end all was no longer the case.

Speaker 1: Mm.

Speaker 2: Right? I think that already brands were recognizing that they need to pay really close attention to how they're showing up on social. Like, they need to get on TikTok Shop, you know? And equally, I think that we've seen a shift towards brands that launched as e-com moving into physical spaces, or at least pop-ups, and, like, trying to create experiences. So I think the brands have always had to meet people where they are.

Speaker 1: Mm.

Speaker 2: And it's just that where people are is changing-

Speaker 1: Yeah

Speaker 2: ... as it always does.

Speaker 1: Yeah. And the idea of brands to publishers, I guess, but the... or the flip flop side of that is creators who become, uh, who, who launch brands, right? On, on-

Speaker 2: Yes

Speaker 1: ... on, or multiple brands.

Speaker 2: They do, but I would say, like, that is not the silver bullet that people like to think it is.

Speaker 1: Mm.

Speaker 2: I think that there's a handful of creators that anything they touch turns to gold, and I think there's a whole lot of brands launched by creators that you or I have never heard of.

Speaker 1: Yeah, totally agree. Um, but one thing they have is the power of audience, I guess, and-

Speaker 2: Yes, but that doesn't-

Speaker 1: ... audience development

Speaker 2: ... always translate to purchase.

Speaker 1: Yeah, yeah. So with the, the clients that you work with, do you, do you help them in terms of building, I guess, you know, reputation, relationships, reach of audience-

Speaker 2: Yeah

Speaker 1: ... community I, I, I think I'm talking to, to a certain extent.

Speaker 2: Yeah, I mean, we are not a team that's, like, setting up partnerships, right? I think that we do brand strategy, brand identity, you know, and then how that brand identity shows up across, like, a very, very wide range of channels, and really thinking about, you know, brand sort of as this multi-media, multi-disciplinary thing. Um, but we're not then, like, running their social accounts. So there's a point at which our work ends and a different team takes over or they bring it in-house.

Speaker 1: Yeah. And when you're working with a, you know, a, a business, could be a startup, could be a scale-up, could actually be a more established company- Is there any commonality in terms of what they get wrong when they're looking at reaching their customer?

Speaker 2: I think that these days there's an understandable but mistaken addiction to data, and I think that what, what I see often happen, and especially with startups and scale-ups, but honestly it's starting to happen with the established businesses too, is that because there are certain activities that, like, give you that immediate ROI hit, if you will, it becomes really hard to justify spend in other areas. But I think that we see, obviously, performance marketing is incredibly important and valuable.

Speaker 1: Mm-hmm.

Speaker 2: But if you're not also investing in other types of activity, like, there is an in- an inevitable erosion that happens over time.

Speaker 1: Yeah, of course. I mean, you're, you're only chasing 5%. What about the 95?

Speaker 2: Exactly.

Speaker 1: Um, when are they gonna come into markets? You can't, you can't neglect the 95.

Speaker 2: 100%. So well said.

Speaker 1: Yeah. So what's, what's the tactic? I mean, you've got to find an equilibrium of sorts. Um, otherwise, hey, you're not bringing in the dollar for next quarter.

Speaker 2: You absolutely have to find an equilibrium. It's gonna be different for every business. I think it's also gonna shift year to year depending on the goals and the stage and what's going on in the market, but I do think that you've got to, like, refill the goodwill coffer, if you will-

Speaker 1: Yeah

Speaker 2: ... with your, like, audience, um, or it's just gonna run out.

Speaker 1: Yeah. And in terms of brand, it's obviously a long-term investment, right? You know, it might pay off in the next two years, three years, or perhaps five years down the line. How should a CMO be presenting that to perhaps a, a finance leader, a CFO on the board?

Speaker 2: I mean, I think it takes a really strong CFO and CEO to be able to, like, empower this, their CMO to not just be living quarter to quarter, and, and it's... I think that's a key part of successful leadership.

Speaker 1: Yeah. Do you think there's a flip side to that? That sometimes marketers demote themselves to, let's be honest, the, uh, the promotions department in terms of how they're looked at by other members of the business and perhaps the board.

Speaker 2: I think that's possible, but I think if we look at the most successful brands that have, like, the greatest brand strength and the greatest longevity, it's because leadership across the board understands the power of brand as a business-building tool.

Speaker 1: Hmm. Yeah. A... One thing I learned, and actually this is through Cannes Lions over, over many years, is that companies that are more creative outperform their competition-

Speaker 2: You heard it here first

Speaker 1: ... uh, and are always the, the leader in the market.

Speaker 2: I believe that, and I think we see examples of that every day, and I also think we see examples that, of businesses that seemed untouchable, and when they stop investing and, like, being the freshest creative voice, um, they run into trouble. I mean, look, I don't work with this brand. Obviously, it's a beloved brand, but, like, look what's happening with Nike right now. I just read today that, like, they're gonna have to do, you know, a whole other cost-cutting measure and, I mean, Nike you thought was, like, impenetrable.

Speaker 1: Yeah. I'm wearing my Jordans.

Speaker 2: I-

Speaker 1: I'm almost in tears.

Speaker 2: Oh, I'm in my, my Drea-

Speaker 2: I'm in my Dre- I'm in my Dreas sneakers right now, but I'm usually in Nikes.

Speaker 1: Yeah, I'm upset to hear that. Um, what brands do you, do you admire at this point in time in terms of, you know, how they show up and how they go to market?

Speaker 2: Well, I won't cheat and name a client, so I'll just say a brand that has been, like, a lifelong love affair for me, and I think they're doing such a good job right now and it makes me happy 'cause I've always loved them, is The Gap.

Speaker 1: Okay.

Speaker 2: Yeah. I... So I, like, grew up with The Gap. I was, like, a '90s kid, like, loved The Gap. I think they've had periods where they've fallen out of fashion and relevance. I stuck with them the whole time.

Speaker 1: Hmm.

Speaker 2: But I think the way they have been able to reignite that brand in the past year or two is so impressive, especially at a point in time where it's so easy to feel that, like, there's not room for a brand like that anymore.

Speaker 1: Yeah. Relevance is a great word. So how do you stay relevant?

Speaker 2: I think that you have to constantly work at it.

Speaker 1: Hmm.

Speaker 2: And I think that actually when we tell the story of the work we do and people say, "Oh, you're... You know, you, you started working with startups. Like, why would an established business hire you?" The answer that I give is because there's not a business in the world today that doesn't need to be thinking about how to future-proof their relevance.

Speaker 1: Hmm.

Speaker 2: Like, if you're just sitting on, resting on your laurels and you're like, "We're the leader. We're always gonna be the leader," there is no category in the world that is safe from disruption. I firmly believe that, from the driest, most esoteric B2B category to, like, the biggest consumer brands.

Speaker 1: Yeah. It's making me think of artists. So, uh, I don't know, you could take, uh, David Bowie as an example or Madonna or Prince or someone else, and that constant reinvention.

Speaker 2: Totally, and every single time with those examples, it came from, like, a really strong point of view.

Speaker 1: Hmm.

Speaker 2: It never felt like they were following the trends. They were setting the trends, right?

Speaker 1: Yeah.

Speaker 2: Like, they had a perspective that they shared with the world, and obviously, you know, art is different than commerce, but I do think there's some overlap, and I think that the strongest brands have their unique voice and their unique perspective. They're not just reacting-

Speaker 1: Hmm

Speaker 2: ... to where the tides are going.

Speaker 1: How do brands develop an identity and, and find their, their voice, their true voice, so they do have that level of uniqueness, um, and so they are perceived as, as a leader?

Speaker 2: So, I mean, for me, it starts with the fundamentals. I really believe that, and I actually think the fundamentals don't change through the years, even so much, uh, as so much of, like, the execution does change. My definition of brand is, like, having a really, really clear understanding of the people who are gonna love you the most and then figuring out, like, why they should care that you exist and constantly reminding them of that.

Speaker 1: Hmm.

Speaker 2: And I think that, like, as that grows and changes and your audience shifts and maybe what's going on in their life changes or maybe your competition has shifted, you have to sort of keep asking yourself, "Why do we matter? Why do we matter?" But at the end of the day, you have to tell a unique story of why someone should care.

Speaker 1: Yeah. And- When you're working with a business, th- there's, look, there's so many channels out there in terms of reaching your audience. How do you help them decide what the right mix is, what that looks like, how they should b- measure, um ... You obviously talked about the fact that there's so much data out there. I mean, we can measure bloody everything, right?

Speaker 2: Yeah.

Speaker 1: But, but how do you help them define what's important and what channels that they should be looking at?

Speaker 2: So that's a great question. You know, we have a separate business that sits under Red Antler Group called Fat Earth that's our media arm. So when it comes to, like, actually defining a media strategy, that is not my core expertise.

Speaker 1: Mm.

Speaker 2: But obviously, as we're thinking through brand strategy, a lot of that is about figuring out, like, where does it make sense for this brand to be in the world? So I am not the person that's advising on, like, the exact split between, you know, Meta and TikTok, but our team is definitely gonna be coming to the table with more of, like, a creative perspective on where can this brand show up that's actually unexpected.

Speaker 1: Mm. And do you find that on the, the client side, that there's a higher level of maturity now in terms of how they look at the world, um, their understanding in terms of how they go to market, um, and how they look at their overall performance and s- and strategy?

Speaker 2: Yeah. I think, again, going back to the prevalence of data, like, clients are definitely kind of closer to the numbers than maybe in the past and closer to the s- the sort of exact results that they're seeking, just because so much is so measurable. Um, but I also think that, like, the really great clients, again, understand that balance we were talking about before.

Speaker 1: Yeah. I, I think it comes across in the, in the way that you talk as well, but so much of your work's been a- about emotion. A- and I think that lacks a fair bit in, in our world. Certainly lacks in B2B. Um, and that whole idea of sort of EQ as well and, and being able to dial that up. So when someone's maybe buying through an assistant, um, yeah, where does emotion sit? You know, I'm on ChatGPT, right? Okay, find me this, find me that, something else.

Speaker 2: Yeah. I mean, I think that, like, it certainly varies category to category sort of how much of a role emotion plays, but you know, going back to where ChatGPT is getting its recommendations from, like, that engine still relies right now on human input, right?

Speaker 1: Mm.

Speaker 2: So I think that there's that, right? It's just, like, how much emotion has already been established in the world that leads you to be the soap that ChatGPT is recommending. I also think that, like, the line between product and brand to me is very blurry, and I think a lot of brand-building is about what happens once it's actually in the person's hands-

Speaker 1: Mm

Speaker 2: ... um, and how do you ensure that it's a great experience that makes them wanna come back for more? And like to me, that is also part of the brand. So even if let's say there's this like really kind of dry utilitarian way that I'm getting into your home and it's just because, you know, the, the bot recommended it, once I'm there, what am I doing? Like, how am I reminding you that I exist?

Speaker 1: Mm.

Speaker 2: What's that experience? What's the packaging like? What's the scent? You know, there's so many... I mean, again, it varies category by category, but I don't think your job ends with the first purchase. That, to me, that's really in some ways where it starts.

Speaker 1: Yeah. I agree. I agree. Um, yeah, it's, it's all senses as well, isn't it? You know, you can taste it, you can smell it, you can feel it.

Speaker 2: Totally.

Speaker 1: You can hear it.

Speaker 2: We are working... Speaking of AI, we have an amazing client called Osmo that is AI scent generation, and they help brands create scent, and not just perfume brands. Like, any brand could sort of incorporate scent as a brand-building tool. It's a fascinating space.

Speaker 1: Wow.

Speaker 2: Yeah.

Speaker 1: And hey, look, I'm, I'm thinking of a naive example, but you go past a, you know, a, a confectionery store.

Speaker 2: It's a great example.

Speaker 1: And of, of course, you know, they, they might have the smell of, um, cocoa beans in the air or something else that... Wow, it's almost like Scooby-Doo, right? You know, the-

Speaker 2: Totally.

Speaker 1: "Woo-hoo-hoo."

Speaker 2: You start salivating.

Speaker 1: Yeah.

Speaker 2: And then imagine you went into that store and you were able to buy a scented candle of that scent that reminds you, "Oh, I love that chocolate" every time you light the candle. You'd want more.

Speaker 1: Yeah. Um, I'm thinking about the idea of, you know, everything being copyable, as it were. Um, and hey, look, I did it today, right? On the way to here, ChatGPT, uh... Actually, no, it was Claude. "Claude, uh, we need some sort of Calendly f- functionality to help around the podcast. Can you scope that out?" Comes back. "Okay, fine. Um, generate a whole load of wireframes." Great. Link them together, give me a, some working model. Okay. I'll, I'll look at it later today and work out where there's gaps and what's not quite right and the experience that I want. Now generate a, an, an SR-, you know, a, a specifications document. Fine. Now just build it autonomously. How long is it gonna take? A day.

Speaker 2: Yeah.

Speaker 1: Yeah. Um, why, why, you know, why... And, and you look at it and think, "God, technology's under threat. Why am I, why am I gonna subscribe to this? Why am I gonna subscribe to that? Why am I gonna subscribe to something else?"

Speaker 2: I think you're totally right, and I think that there are going to be a lot of SaaS businesses that are gonna have to be taking, like, a very hard look at their-

Speaker 1: Yeah

Speaker 2: ... offering in the next year. Um, I would say that where does defensibility come from? You know, if you really are just a set of features that can be replicated by somebody on their own, you probably aren't gonna survive this era.

Speaker 1: Mm.

Speaker 2: But, you know, there's no ongoing service in that- Just y- um, scenario that you just described to me, there's no team that's helping you figure out what's best for your business and staying involved as you go-

Speaker 1: Sure

Speaker 2: ... and making sure it's all working and that you're optimizing it. You're on your own.

Speaker 1: Yeah.

Speaker 2: Right? And certain simple things you will end up making on your own, but I think that when it comes to more complex things of how you're really running your business-

Speaker 1: Mm

Speaker 2: ... I still believe there will be room for human expertise.

Speaker 1: Yeah. I mean, that example was just purely a transactional task.

Speaker 2: Sure.

Speaker 1: And that's it.

Speaker 2: Yeah.

Speaker 1: Yeah.

Speaker 2: It is a commodity-

Speaker 1: Yeah

Speaker 2: ... what you just said.

Speaker 1: And do you think that it's also driving businesses to become more of a utility for their, their customer base? I quite like the idea of useful brands and, um, SaaS companies surviving because they become more of a utility, and I love the idea of layering expertise.

Speaker 2: Yeah. I mean, I think that where SaaS companies will really be able to differentiate is, you know, unique expertise that leads to the creation of a set of services that would be hard to replicate, right? And service. You know?

Speaker 1: Mm.

Speaker 2: And, and just, like, are there people on the other end that are gonna help me ensure that, like, I have the exact right stack and that, that I'm getting the most out of it and that, you know, as my business grows, I'm still getting what I need. Like, that, that degree of support w- would be the reason that I still pay for certain SaaS subscriptions-

Speaker 1: Yeah

Speaker 2: ... versus just building it ourselves.

Speaker 1: Yeah. I agree. Um, and at the same time, I think we... I touched on consultancy earlier, but agencies are not much different in terms of business model.

Speaker 2: Yeah.

Speaker 1: So, you know, time and materials, you know, et cetera, et cetera. People businesses charging out people, so on and so forth. How do you see agencies evolving as, obviously, parts of their business model are under threat from the proliferation of AI?

Speaker 2: Sure. So couple answers here. One is, when I launched Red Antler, there was this website called 99designs. I don't know if you remember this, where you could literally go on and for $99 you could buy a logo, okay?

Speaker 1: Yeah.

Speaker 2: None of the businesses that bought their logo on 99designs are still here today to tell the tale, if they didn't end up rebranding. So cheap, bad design has always been available to anybody who's seeking it.

Speaker 1: Yep.

Speaker 2: Um, I would also say, because I think that I... Again, I don't wanna be naive, and I think that, you know, generative AI is getting better and better and better, right? It's getting really, really good.

Speaker 1: Mm.

Speaker 2: The only value of a brand is comparative. There is no intrinsic value to what we do. We're not making art. We just have to be better than the other guy. So if everybody has access to these tools, then you need a different way to stand out, right?

Speaker 1: Of course.

Speaker 2: 'Cause if everybody can go in and sort of prompt then and have a great-looking website, then it's not gonna be the website that helps businesses win.

Speaker 1: Yeah.

Speaker 2: Our job is to help businesses win.

Speaker 1: Yeah. I agree. I mean, I'll look at a website and, yeah, Claude built that.

Speaker 2: Sure. Me too-

Speaker 1: And, and-

Speaker 2: ... and I'm really sick of their aesthetic.

Speaker 1: Yeah.

Speaker 1: Or I'll look at something else and go, "Oh, yeah, that was GPT," that's been something else, and so on.

Speaker 2: I also receive newsletters where it's like, "Oh, Claude wrote that" and I unsubscribe-

Speaker 1: Yeah

Speaker 2: ... because I don't need someone else's Claude thoughts in my inbox.

Speaker 1: Yeah. I agree.

Speaker 2: I can ask Claude myself.

Speaker 1: Yeah.

Speaker 1: Um, I think what we're describing there is same-ism.

Speaker 2: Yes.

Speaker 1: Yeah.

Speaker 2: Exactly.

Speaker 1: Um, and to be successful, you need to better differentiate and stand out.

Speaker 2: 100%, and I think that there will be new ways that businesses have to seek to stand out because of generative AI, but the challenge will remain the same-

Speaker 1: Mm

Speaker 2: ... is how do you tell a unique story?

Speaker 1: Yeah. Yeah. I think in, in the case of B2B, for instance, um, "GPT, I need a white paper, uh, it needs to be a white paper about X. This is our product," so on. Uh, all you're getting is the crappy white papers of the past rather than anything that's new or anything that's got a great story arc or something that's human and compelling about it.

Speaker 2: Totally, and we see that with campaign ideas, and we see that with design ideas. It's just drawing from what's been done before-

Speaker 1: Yeah

Speaker 2: ... which, again, can be really helpful to, like, get you started or to pressure test or just, like, generate a lot to get the wheels turning, but you're not gonna get somewhere new through that approach.

Speaker 1: Yeah. And that also comes down to experience, isn't it? You know, so you might have a jam with GPTs or, or, you know, number of AIs or whatever, and you could be trying to come up with a strapline for a business or something else, but it then comes down to choice and selection and the expertise that needs to ride over the top of this.

Speaker 2: Yes, exactly. Expertise, strategy, instinct, which comes from experience, you know, and, and bravery. Can I say that?

Speaker 1: Yeah.

Speaker 2: Is that too lofty a word?

Speaker 1: Bravery's great. I love it. Yeah. Um, I'm looking at the UK, for instance, in the job market. A lot of, uh, early stage jobs have been a- eradicated, and I think that's because companies have been very fast to put automations in place, put, um, sort of cost savings in place, um, a rush for efficiency. Uh, at the same time thinking, "Okay, if we're more efficient, we're, we're more profitable" but neglecting the base of talent that's actually gonna be the future leaders of those companies. How do you look at that, and how do you mitigate against this?

Speaker 2: I am so glad you brought this up, John, because I think about this all the time.

Speaker 1: Mm.

Speaker 2: And just, like, quick digression, about seven years ago, I feel like it was really hard for any of my clients to hire a CMO because there was nobody who had the right number of years of experience who had grown up in the age of performance marketing.

Speaker 1: Mm.

Speaker 2: So the people who were senior enough were kind of, like, old school, and then the sort of people who really understood the new channels were young. We're gonna face the same problem in, like, seven, eight years in our industry if nobody's hiring entry level.

Speaker 1: Yeah.

Speaker 2: I don't know where everyone thinks this is heading. Like, we have to be hiring entry level and training up the next generation of talent. It's a must.

Speaker 1: Yeah, in my mind it's crazy.

Speaker 2: Yeah

Speaker 1: You know, if you're hiring younger people, they're kind of AI natives-

Speaker 2: 100%

Speaker 1: ... in the first place.

Speaker 2: And truly some of my best, best team members are people that we hired more or less fresh out of school, whether that was, you know, 10 years ago and they're still with us to this day-

Speaker 1: Yeah

Speaker 2: ... or recently, and yeah, to your point, the people on the team who are best at AI, who are, like, convincing the entire company to, like, convert over. I'm gonna shout out Lizzie if she's listening. You know, but, like, we've got these people that... And they understand it so much more natively and inherently than, you know-

Speaker 1: Yeah

Speaker 2: ... oldies like me.

Speaker 1: Yeah. Hey, look, we're still Gen X, though.

Speaker 2: Yeah, exactly.

Speaker 2: The coolest generation.

Speaker 1: So that's kind of cool.

Speaker 2: Yeah.

Speaker 1: Well, that's what we tell ourselves.

Speaker 2: Oh, I mean, I think everyone can agree, right?

Speaker 1: Yeah.

Speaker 2: The best music. Yeah.

Speaker 1: That's true. That's true. Um, yeah. Um, I think you talked earlier about the idea of sort of synthesized data as well. What's your point of view on that? So, um, you might be looking to get some research done, or, uh, understand more about how potential consumers who want your product might react to certain messages. So what's, what's your take on, um, synthesized data?

Speaker 2: Like synthetic data you mean?

Speaker 1: Yeah.

Speaker 2: Um, I don't trust it yet.

Speaker 1: Okay.

Speaker 2: I am very interested in following that space because I do think that consumer research is incredibly important, and if there are ways to get, like, quicker, accurate reads, that will be invaluable.

Speaker 1: Mm.

Speaker 2: I am not sure that we're there yet. I'm... Uh, what we've actually been u- We had a... We do the opposite. We use a tool that's actually a AI moderator that interviews real humans. So we're-

Speaker 1: Oh, wow. Okay

Speaker 2: ... Yeah. And, and it's great-

Speaker 1: Yeah

Speaker 2: ... because it, it has the efficiency, but at the end of the day, we're still talking to real people. I'm, I'm not yet convinced that the synthetic data is there, but I think it will get there eventually.

Speaker 1: Yeah. I love that. I love the idea that you... What is it? Is it interviewing people?

Speaker 2: Yeah.

Speaker 1: Yeah? Okay.

Speaker 2: Yeah.

Speaker 1: So what? It'll join a Zoom call or something like that, or-

Speaker 2: Yeah, I don't know the-

Speaker 1: How does it work?

Speaker 2: My team would know the exact mechanics of it-

Speaker 1: Yeah

Speaker 2: ... but we made the decision that at this moment in time, that information is actually more valuable than the synthetic data.

Speaker 1: Okay. And then you'll report back to you. You know, "Here's the knowledge from the conversation. Here's the insights that are extracted-

Speaker 2: Yeah

Speaker 1: ... from that, and this is what can be done."

Speaker 2: And it's cheaper and faster because we don't need a human moderator, although we do have a human moderator for more in-depth research.

Speaker 1: Yeah.

Speaker 2: But for quick, you know, quick reads.

Speaker 1: Yeah.

Speaker 2: Yeah.

Speaker 1: So it gives you scale.

Speaker 2: Yeah.

Speaker 1: Yeah. That's neat. Um, we touched, you know, touched on the idea of AI removing parts of business models and, and so on. Do you think in some ways that we're almost going back to the start? So I'm thinking about retail. Um, hey, we're in America, so I'm gonna use a Midwest example. Uh, you know, in the days of the railway and the, the, you know, the dude needing the pickax, the shovel, a pair of boots, a new shirt, something else, some braces, whatever.

Speaker 1: You know, can of beans. Um-

Speaker 2: Love the image-

Speaker 1: Let's go-

Speaker 2: ... that you're conjuring

Speaker 1: ... let's go, let's go stereotype, right?

Speaker 2: Yeah, I can picture him perfectly.

Speaker 1: I watch, I watch, I watch the movies. But they'd go to a counter service, right?

Speaker 2: Mm-hmm.

Speaker 1: And say, "Hey, uh, this is what I'm looking for. This is what I need. Need, need a new pair of boots, need a shovel, need some food." Yeah. Uh, the guy would just go and look behind the counter. "Yeah, we've got that. We don't have this. But I can get the, this in for you, and you're just around the corner f- from the store. We can drop it off for you-

Speaker 2: Yeah

Speaker 1: ... or you can come in this time next week," right?

Speaker 2: Sure.

Speaker 1: Um, and I'm thinking you fast-forward a bit and you get to the early department stores, and then fast-forward much further, e-commerce is just a replication of department stores, no more, no less. Um, and I'm using my AI to go find stuff, so I, I don't really need to go into the site and have the experience at the site and so on, and choice.

Speaker 2: Yeah.

Speaker 1: Uh, perhaps there's too much choice.

Speaker 2: Sure.

Speaker 1: Uh, and me having to do the filtering and whatever else, which feels like a pain. Uh, in some ways it feels like we're maybe going full circle, but it's the AI walking up to the dude in the store, apart from he's been removed as well, saying, "This is what I need. This is what I'm looking for."

Speaker 2: I mean, I, I feel Amazon more or less already plays the role that you're describing-

Speaker 1: Mm

Speaker 2: ... of the, the boots, pickax, bean store, you know?

Speaker 1: Yeah.

Speaker 2: Um, I'm... That's where I'm buying my boots and pickaxes-

Speaker 1: Yeah

Speaker 2: ... and beans.

Speaker 1: Yeah.

Speaker 2: I don't know about you. Um, and there's a lot that I buy on Amazon, I'll admit it-

Speaker 1: Yeah

Speaker 2: ... you know, without shame, and I... That's where I buy my dog food and my light bulbs and my garbage bags, but there's a lot I also don't buy on Amazon, and I think that if you really wanna look at the history of commerce, I mean, the department store really came to be because it was actually a social space for women outside of the home-

Speaker 1: Yeah

Speaker 2: ... and one of the few places that they actually could build community and have an experience outside of sort of the isolating environment of their home, and I think that still matters too.

Speaker 1: Yeah.

Speaker 2: You know? I think that retail's gonna have to work harder, for sure, to get people, you know, out of the little screen and out of the LLM, but we're seeing a return to physical retail-

Speaker 1: Sure

Speaker 2: ... and a yearning for incredible real-world experiences.

Speaker 1: Yeah. That's exactly what I'm thinking of, is that a rise of the boutique, the niche, the independent, um, as opposed to companies that just frankly take in, you know, a million or a half a million product feeds-

Speaker 2: Yeah

Speaker 1: ... and they're just SKUs and there's, there's no, you know, there's, there's nothing, there's no background behind that. There's no passion behind it.

Speaker 2: Totally.

Speaker 1: Uh, there's no love behind it, and they're just aggregating up inventory. Uh, which was great in the days of search. It gave you more reach, more people coming in, uh, more stuff for people to search through, versus the independent who- Has been more cautious in terms of the selection and, and they're kind of curators and kind of bastions of, um, great products, but also great content around those products.

Speaker 2: Totally. And I think that the role of curation in retail is gonna become more and more important. And look, again, maybe there's a world in which your closet gets to know you so well that it's curating for you, but, like, what about the fun of discovery?

Speaker 1: Mm.

Speaker 2: And what about the fun of tactility? And like, I mean, I'm a shopper. I love to shop, and like, I don't wanna just be told the answer. I wanna look at all the stuff, and I wanna touch it, and I want to experience it, and maybe do that with a friend, you know?

Speaker 1: Yeah. Yeah. That's what it's about, isn't it? I love the idea of taking a friend with you, and, uh, uh, how do I look in this? And-

Speaker 2: Exactly

Speaker 1: ... perhaps I should get a slightly bigger or smaller size, or, um, perhaps I should try something that is not something I would normally go for and see how that looks.

Speaker 2: So I love that point because my biggest fear with everything being so algorithmic- uh, algorithmically driven is it only recommends where you've already been. Back to our point before about you don't get anywhere new-

Speaker 1: Yeah

Speaker 2: ... I don't wanna just be told, "Here's another black T-shirt that looks exactly like all the other black T-shirts that you like," you know? I want someone to push me to buy the red one.

Speaker 1: Exactly. The world is saying, right?

Speaker 2: Yes.

Speaker 1: Yeah, yeah. Yeah, I've been trying to get outside my comfort zone, but-

Speaker 2: It's hard

Speaker 1: ... Kayla, I'm back to black for the answer there.

Speaker 2: Yeah, I am too.

Speaker 2: But look, I have little jewels, so.

Speaker 1: There we go. Um, a few quick fire questions. So a, a brand that you might admire at this point in time that's doing something particularly neat, um, or perhaps it's a, you know, a newcomer that's caught your attention for a, a particular reason.

Speaker 2: Yeah. Can I, can I shout out one of my clients for this?

Speaker 1: Of course. I'd love to hear.

Speaker 2: Okay, great.

Speaker 1: Yeah.

Speaker 2: Um, one of my favorites that we have launched in recent past is actually CPG food. So, um, it's a labneh brand called Bezi, and they've been growing like mad. Um, and you know, labneh has not really made its way into the American palate in the same way that like hummus has. It's, it's still fairly-

Speaker 1: Yeah

Speaker 2: ... new for people. So it's been incredible to me to see how the, the founder, you know, who's amazing, has really been able to like introduce this, you know, food that might be hard to pronounce, people aren't quite sure how it's gonna taste, and she's just, you know, continues to grow and has gotten an amazing response.

Speaker 1: Mm-hmm.

Speaker 2: And, um, I love seeing that because I think it, again, it shows, you know, you think, "Oh, the grocery aisle is so crowded, and like there's never room for something new," but I, I do think there's always room for something new, and I think people wanna discover new things and expand their horizons.

Speaker 1: Yeah. Great example. Um, a go-to resource or just a, uh, or perhaps even a methodology in terms of h- you know, how you get inspired and how you stay infused.

Speaker 2: So my secret is that I read a ton of fiction, and that's how I spend a lot of my leisure time is just reading novels, which I think is an incredible way to sort of get outside your own head, build empathy, experience things that you've never experienced-

Speaker 1: Yeah

Speaker 2: ... you know, through a new lens. I also read a couple great Substacks regularly. I read Emily Sundberg's Feed Me. I read, um, Rachel Carton's Link in Bio, so that's more on the business side. But I'd say the majority of my leisure time is, is reading books.

Speaker 1: Yeah. And lastly, going back to the, the younger you, or, um, actually just a, a younger individual who's looking at the world of marketing, media, or advertising, maybe tech, or perhaps actually thinking, "You know what? Fuck that. I'm gonna set up my own business," what advice would you provide them at that early stage?

Speaker 2: Well, if they're gonna set up their own business, I'd say have a damn good reason that you're doing that, because it's really hard, and I think that, you know, it can look glamorous from the outside, but it's a very long, you know, hard road ahead. Um, so I think you really need to be driven because you have an idea that you feel needs to be built and not just like, "Oh, wouldn't it be fun not to have a boss?" Um, uh, and I think that, you know, reading a ton, writing a ton, um, talking to as many people as you can, just remembering like the importance of living in this incredible world that we are lucky to be alive on and being out there in the world and not just sort of myopically staring at a screen.

Speaker 1: Fantastic. It's been, uh, amazing to have you on the show today. Thank you so much for your time, and yeah, I tot- totally agree, and, and your pearls and, of wisdom and, and sharing your knowledge with us.

Speaker 2: Thank you. Great to talk to you.

“The only value of a brand is comparative. There is no intrinsic value to what we do.”

Emily Heyward, Red Antler · Episode 171
The Rewrite

Stay close to the conversation.

The conversations and intelligence worth knowing about.

About the guest

Emily Heyward

Co-founder and CEO, Red Antler · Season 7, Episode 171

Emily Heyward is co-founder and CEO of Red Antler, the brand company she started with her co-founder in 2007 and which, by her account, is now 19 years old. She is known for building brands at the highest stakes moments, from pre-launch startups to established businesses that need to tell a new story, and for work with companies including Ramp, the shopping platform Daydream and the labneh brand Bezi.

Read the interview Full profile

Share