Interview · · 7 min read
Brand value is comparative, never intrinsic. Relevance has to be earned again every year. No category is safe.
Emily Heyward, co-founder and CEO of Red Antler, argues that in an era where every company claims AI and anyone can prompt a decent website, brand value is only ever comparative. She makes the case against the addiction to the measurable 5 percent, for refilling the goodwill of an audience, and for keeping human expertise, curation and entry-level hiring. Her blunt thesis: the job is simply to be better than the other guy.
Emily Heyward, Co-founder and CEO, Red Antler. Interviewed by John Horsley.
Listen while you read:Better Than Default
0:0042:00Nineteen years telling new-to-the-world stories at the highest stakes moments
The setup.
Heyward traces the pull to a childhood of pop culture, television and magazines, cutting out ads she liked and hanging them on her walls. The road into advertising was a wandering one, but she was drawn fast to a discipline that converged creativity with thinking hard about people and what makes them tick. She started Red Antler with her co-founder in 2007, so they are 19 years old. The early focus was launching new businesses, often pre-launch startups, and that remains part of the work, but they now serve businesses of every scale and industry. Their reason for being is to tell new-to-the-world stories at the highest stakes moments.
On the lost advantage.
When they started, there was little conversation about building a brand from the beginning, so just showing up with a well-conceived, strategic, beautifully executed brand gave a business an advantage. That is not true anymore. Everybody recognises they need to look good and have their story down, so it is far more competitive, and the pressure to show up across a myriad of channels from day one is much greater, with an insane amount of content needed to keep fuelling those engines.
AI has become as meaningless a word as tech, or dot-com
On throwing AI into the deck.
Every company now claims to be an AI business, and Heyward thinks that makes the claim worthless. Everybody is throwing AI into the deck to increase valuations and interest. AI has become synonymous with tech, which is an equally meaningless word, like the businesses that put dot-com in their name in an earlier era. The work is to help businesses tell a story that may incorporate AI but transcends it, speaking to the greater value they offer and why they matter more than others claiming the same thing.
On the worked example.
Ramp came to Red Antler already seeing incredible traction but needing to solidify its narrative to break through with CFOs bombarded by platforms and SaaS tools. Red Antler helped them tell a story about the values of the businesses that use Ramp, positioning it as the platform for the smart, forward-thinking leader who wants visibility and control rather than just racking up points, speaking directly to the CFO in a way no one else was.
No utilitarian experience replaces a brand people actually love
On the utilitarian floor.
It is a watershed moment and she would be naive to claim nothing will change. People who want a purely utilitarian retail experience can already get it from Google or Amazon. But experiences that build something real still draw business away, as with Daydream, a conversational AI shopping platform that competes with Google but brings a fashion sensibility for people who care about clothes and brands. There will always be room to build brands that connect with people; you just have to find new ways in.
On where recommendations come from.
People are starting to go straight into their LLM for a recommendation, and those recommendations pull from Reddit, Google reviews, articles and press mentions, all generated by quality and by people telling their friends. It shows up differently, but the fundamentals still matter a lot. And creator brands are not the silver bullet people think: a handful turn anything to gold, but there are plenty launched by creators you have never heard of, because audience does not always translate to purchase.
“The only value of a brand is comparative.”
Put yourself forward or recommend a guest for us to consider.
Request an interview →Most companies try to reach senior decision makers. We give them a reason to engage.
Partner with Us →Have your say.Add your voice to the conversation.
Voices is where senior practitioners share what they're seeing, what they believe and what they'd change.
Become a Voice →The mistaken addiction to data erodes the brand it ignores
On the 5% trap.
The common mistake is an understandable but mistaken addiction to data. Because certain activities deliver an immediate return, it becomes hard to justify spend elsewhere, even for established businesses. Performance marketing is important, but without investment in other activity there is an inevitable erosion over time. You are only chasing the 5%; you cannot neglect the 95. You have to refill the goodwill coffer with your audience or it runs out.
On brand as a business-building tool.
It takes a really strong CFO and CEO to empower a CMO not to live only quarter to quarter, and that is a key part of successful leadership. The brands with the greatest strength and longevity have it because leadership across the board understands brand as a business-building tool. She believes more creative companies outperform, and points to Nike, a brand you thought was impenetrable, now cost-cutting after losing its freshest creative voice.
The only value of a brand is comparative, so be better than the other guy
On future-proofing relevance.
You have to constantly work at relevance. There is not a business in the world today that does not need to think about how to future-proof its relevance. Rest on your laurels, assuming you will always be the leader, and there is no category in the world safe from disruption, from the driest B2B category to the biggest consumer brands. Like Bowie, Madonna and Prince, the strongest brands come from a strong point of view; they set trends rather than react to the tides.
On being better than the other guy.
Cheap, bad design has always been available, long before AI. Generative AI is getting really good, but the only value of a brand is comparative; there is no intrinsic value, they are not making art, they just have to be better than the other guy. If everybody can prompt a good-looking website, it will not be the website that helps a business win. She is sick of Claude's aesthetic, and when a newsletter reads like Claude wrote it she unsubscribes, because she does not need someone else's Claude thoughts in her inbox. The answer to same-ism is unchanged: tell a unique story, carried by expertise, strategy, instinct and bravery.
Your job does not end with the first purchase
On emotion after the sale.
Emotion varies by category, but the recommendation engine still relies on human input, so the question is how much emotion has already been established to make you the soap ChatGPT recommends. The line between product and brand is very blurry, and much of brand-building is what happens once the product is in someone's hands: the experience, the packaging, the scent. Even if a bot got it into your home, the job is to remind them you exist. The job does not end with the first purchase; in some ways that is where it starts. Red Antler's client Osmo generates scent for brands as exactly that kind of tool.
“I don't need someone else's Claude thoughts in my inbox.”
SaaS and agencies that are a replicable set of features will not survive
On defensibility.
A lot of SaaS businesses will have to take a hard look at their offering. If you really are just a set of features that can be replicated by somebody on their own, you probably will not survive this era. What endures is ongoing service and unique expertise: people on the other end who make sure you have the right stack and keep getting what you need as you grow. Simple things you will build yourself, but the complex work of running a business still has room for human expertise.
Hiring entry level is a must, not a cost to cut
On the coming talent gap.
Heyward thinks about this all the time. About seven years ago it was hard for clients to hire a CMO because the senior people were old school and the people who understood new channels were young. The industry will repeat that in seven or eight years if nobody hires entry level. We have to be hiring entry level and training up the next generation of talent; it is a must. Some of her best team members were hired fresh out of school, and the people best at AI understand it far more natively than, as she puts it, oldies like her.
On synthetic data.
She does not trust synthetic data yet. Consumer research is incredibly important and quicker, accurate reads would be invaluable, but she is not sure they are there. Red Antler does the opposite, using an AI moderator that interviews real humans, keeping the efficiency while still talking to real people, with a human moderator for deeper work.
A return to physical retail and the fun of being pushed to buy the red one
On curation and discovery.
Amazon already plays the role of the boots, pickaxe and bean store, and that is where she buys dog food, light bulbs and garbage bags, but there is plenty she does not buy there. The department store began as a social space, and that still matters. Retail will have to work harder to pull people out of the little screen, but there is a return to physical retail and a yearning for real experiences. Her biggest fear with everything being algorithmically driven is that it only recommends where you have already been. She does not want another identical black T-shirt; she wants someone to push her to buy the red one. Curation is why even a crowded grocery aisle has room for something new, like the labneh brand Bezi.
On what she would tell a founder.
If you are going to start your own business, have a damn good reason, because it is really hard and a long road even if it looks glamorous. Be driven by an idea you feel needs to be built, not just the thought of not having a boss. Read a ton, write a ton, talk to as many people as you can, and remember the importance of living in this incredible world and being out in it rather than myopically staring at a screen.
Hear the full conversation. Follow Business of Marketing.
10 · The board question
If performance marketing is delivering the immediate return, what are we investing today to refill the goodwill of our audience before our relevance quietly erodes?